The Futility of Astrology: A Scientific Perspective

As I reflect on the topic of astrology, I'm struck by how illogical and unsound its principles are. Wood's response to the toast 'to physics and metaphysics' is particularly insightful: a physicist has an idea, and so does anyone else who claims to possess knowledge.

Astrology, which claims to predict our personalities, futures, and destinies based on the positions of stars and planets at the time of birth, is a pseudoscience that lacks any scientific basis. The idea that two identical twins born in the same place and time could have vastly different lives defies logic and challenges astrologers to explain their failures.

In reality, astrology is nothing more than a form of vague advice-dispensing, masquerading as predictive science. Take, for example, a typical horoscope: 'Demand more of yourself' or 'A compromise will help ease tension.' These are not predictions but rather generic pieces of advice that could apply to anyone.

The fact that astrologers themselves cannot agree on the meaning of a given horoscope is further evidence of its lack of validity. Moreover, astrology has been tested in the lives of twins, and the results are nothing short of astonishing: one twin may live a life marked by tragedy and hardship, while their identical sibling enjoys a long and prosperous life.

And yet, despite its lack of scientific merit, astrology continues to be widely published and accepted as a legitimate form of wisdom. In contrast, there are hardly any newspapers that devote space to astronomy or other scientific disciplines.

In contemporary Western society, it's easy to find magazines on astrology at newsstands, but astronomically-themed publications are much harder to come by. This disparity speaks volumes about our society's priorities and values.

As a scientist, I've often been asked 'What sign are you?' or 'Are you a Gemini?' – questions that are more trivial than profound. Meanwhile, scientific concepts like supernova explosions and Mars Rovers rarely receive mention in popular culture. It's time to recognize the futility of astrology and promote a more scientifically-informed understanding of the world.

Contact carl sagan goodreads